Topic > What effect does physical evidence have in a criminal trial and…

In the criminal justice system, the best chance for a fair trial and justice lies in cases that include physical evidence. Physical evidence, whether fibers, fingerprints, or DNA, can provide the jury with proof beyond a reasonable doubt. Physical evidence can convict a criminal or free an innocent man. It can bring closure to the families and law enforcement dealing with the cases. The following cases will show the effect of physical evidence in a criminal trial and the vast impact it can have. For each case I will look at how the physical evidence was important to the case and whether or not it could have made a bigger difference if the presentation of the evidence had been different. The five cases are: the Mosley case, the Warren case, the Chandler case, the Frediani case and the Swift case. First there is the Michael Mosley case. Michael Mosley was convicted of murder a couple of ten years ago (Wurtman, 2011). Two other men were cleared when Mosley's DNA was found at the murder scene (Crowe II, 2012). Additionally, there was a palm print on the wall and additional DNA on the bedroom sheets (Wurtman, 2011). In contrast to all the evidence, Mosley's attorney offered an alternative reason and painted a picture of several events to explain the presence of Mosley's DNA (Wurtman, 2011). However, the jury did not believe the defense version and the conviction of Michael Mosley led to a request to work on the DNA database and the most interesting fact is that Michael Mosley had no DNA in the system until seven years after the crime. (Crowe II, 2012). I believe the physical evidence was adequately presented given Michael Mosley's conviction. I also believe that an expanded DNA database could lead law enforcement to locate criminals in...... middle of paper ...... January 27, 2012, from http://www.signonsandiego.com/ uniontrib/20080128/ news_1m28dnabook.htmlSpringer, P. (2009, April 28). Portland Police Homicide Unit Solves Murder from 1976. Oregon and Southwest Washington News · OPB News. Retrieved February 27, 2012, from http://news.opb.org/article/portland-police-cold-case-homicide-unit-solves-1976-murder/Thalji, J. (2011, November 16). Oba Chandler dies from 1989 rapes, murder of mother and teenage daughters. News about Tampa Bay, Florida | Tampa Bay Times/St. Pete Times. Retrieved February 26, 2012, from http://www.tampabay.com/news/publicsafety/crime/article1201940.eceWurtmann, B. (2011, June 1). The jury deliberates on the fate of accused murderer Michael Mosley. WNYT.com - Albany, NY - Capital Region News, Weather and Sports from NEWSCHANNEL 13. Retrieved February 27, 2012, from http://wnyt.com/article/stories/s2137309.shtml